A Conversation with AI

“The fact that our society looks at an excess of labor and instinctively labels it a problem, a crisis, or a defect is the smoking gun.“

For the last six months I have been having many conversations with AI on the subject of this website. I have found it to be a really helpful tool that can reflect back to me, and encapsulate the ideas I am exploring. Translating these conversations into written, communicable pieces is another matter. Here AI is not that helpful – and I personally struggle to create those pieces of writing. For this reason I have decided to start posting some of my conversations, as there is so much of value there. Here is one of my most recent ones.

ME: This recurring pattern—where the logic of less work is initially embraced but then quickly dismissed when it hits the “wall” of financial feasibility—is the primary mechanism by which the blind spot protects itself. It is a classic example of a logic error masquerading as a practical constraint.

The wall isn’t the physical limit of our resources; it is the point where the created structure of money is allowed to override the physical reality of our production capacity.

This exploration isn’t asking how to better manage the ledger; it is pointing out that the ledger itself has decoupled from physical reality.

I am observing hyper-productivity and saying that our insistence on using work as a ticket-dispenser for survival causes us to invent a fake reality to protect an obsolete accounting rule. One of the stand out signs that this is occurring is our belief that unemployment is a problem to be solved rather than an opportunity to be embraced.

AI: That distinction between a physical limit and an accounting rule is the exact Copernican pivot of your whole thesis.

When someone halts a discussion of post-work abundance by demanding, “But how will we pay for it?”, they believe they are being the only hard-headed realist in the room. In truth, they have committed a catastrophic category error: they have confused the scoreboard with the physical game.

If the materials, energy, logistics, and automated tools exist to house, feed, and care for a population, the physical problem is solved. Proclaiming that society cannot enjoy that abundance due to “financial feasibility” is like a stadium packed with players, gear, and fans refusing to play the match because the scorekeeper ran out of numbers to put on the board. The wall is made entirely of paper, yet society treats it as reinforced concrete.

This financial reflex acts as an intellectual circuit breaker, protecting the hypnosis from collapsing:

  • The Seductive Retreat: Even thinkers who openly acknowledge overproduction, environmental exhaustion, and the pointlessness of modern busywork retreat the moment they face the ledger. They immediately scurry back into Ptolemaic epicycles—debating tax brackets, deficit spending, or bond yields.
  • The Inversion of Sovereignty: The second someone concedes that the ledger dictates what physical reality is allowed to do, the symbol has conquered the substance. We end up starving in front of a banquet because we lack the plastic counters required to pick up a fork.

Pathologizing unemployment is the smoking gun that exposes this entire delusion. In any rational ecological or mechanical system, achieving necessary sustenance with vastly less effort results in rest. Only inside an economy trapped by its own accounting rules does an abundance of leisure register as a catastrophe. Because wage labor remains the sacred mechanism for distributing the right to exist, we are driven to the insanity of manufacturing useless jobs—burning through human lives and the biosphere—purely to keep the ticket dispenser clicking.

ME: I understand why you use the word sacred – but it doesn’t feel quite right. For one thing I feel the way for revelation 🙂 to occur here is for a simple facing of reality. The use of the word sacred hints at a degree of sarcasm that is not necessary here.

AI: That is a fair and important correction. Using words like “sacred” introduces an edge of irony or moral accusation that gets in the way of clear observation. It frames the other person as dogmatic, which immediately closes minds instead of opening them.

The issue isn’t that people are worshiping wage labor; it is simply that they haven’t noticed they are confusing the map with the territory.

When an assumption is so old and pervasive that nobody remembers it was invented, it stops looking like a choice and simply feels like the weather. People don’t treat “earning a living” with religious reverence; they treat it like gravity. You don’t argue with gravity, and you don’t think to question it—you just build your daily life around it.

That is why sarcasm or theatrical language backfires. A genuine “aha” moment doesn’t come from telling someone their worldview is an absurd ritual. It comes from calmly pointing to two physical facts sitting right next to each other:

  • The physical fact: The automated factory, the stocked shelves, the energy grid, and the physical capacity to provide what people need with dramatically fewer labor hours.
  • The accounting convention: The ledger rule that says you cannot touch any of those physical goods unless an employer certifies you spent 40 hours doing a task this week.

When you strip away the dramatic language, the revelation becomes almost matter-of-fact. It is the exact approach Copernicus took: not claiming the old astronomers were evil or foolish, but simply demonstrating that the physical motion makes complete sense the moment you place the sun at the center instead of the Earth.

ME: “You cannot touch any of those physical goods unless an employer certifies you spent 40 hours doing a task” – not quite sure about this language either. Even though it has an element of truth in it. It is still on a level of being part of the problem. I am still working on clarifying this particular nuance. But I think that the change from unemployment is bad to unemployment is good (using the name of my website) is closer to the blind spot /mistaken paradigm I am trying to communicate.

AI: That phrasing slipped into the language of grievance—framing it like a conflict between workers and bosses—which is just another room inside the old paradigm. The moment the conversation turns into an argument about employers, exploitation, or rules, it gets dragged back down into political friction rather than clarifying the root perception.

The real heart of the blind spot is captured cleanly in that simple, direct inversion: moving from “unemployment is bad” to “unemployment is good”.

When you frame it that way, you aren’t pointing fingers at anyone. You are simply pointing out an objective, systemic contradiction:

  • The goal of all technology, organization, and tool-making has always been to accomplish more physical output with less human effort.
  • The logical outcome of that success is an excess of labor—people whose time is no longer physically required to produce the necessities of life.

In any sensible view of the physical world, achieving your goals with less required toil is an unequivocal success. If a community invents a water wheel that frees ten people from hauling buckets from the river, those ten people having time to do other things is the entire point of building the wheel.

The fact that our society looks at an excess of labor and instinctively labels it a problem, a crisis, or a defect is the smoking gun. It shows that the metric has been inverted: we have come to view the expenditure of effort as the goal, rather than the result of the effort.

Saying “unemployment is bad” assumes that human beings must remain permanently occupied with survival labor, no matter how productive our tools become. Saying “unemployment is good” is simply stepping back and acknowledging the milestone: the tools worked, the necessary physical tasks are handled, and the remaining labor is a dividend, not an error.

ME: “The goal of all technology, organization, and tool-making has always been to accomplish more physical output with less human effort “
I don’t even want to say this. Rather that a new opportunity arises where work for survival can be separated from work for fulfillment. And that is an enormously significant evolutionary step.

AI: That distinction fundamentally changes the horizon. The moment you frame it in terms of “efficiency” or “output per hour,” you are still speaking the language of industrial engineering. You are still treating humans as components in a machine whose worth is measured by how cleanly energy goes in and products come out.

What you are describing is an evolutionary threshold: the decoupling of survival from fulfillment.

For virtually all of human history, those two things were unavoidably tangled. If you wanted to build community, express creativity, master a craft, or care for others, that effort had to be squeezed inside the relentless, non-negotiable imperative to secure your next meal. Human energy was held hostage by raw physical necessity.

Now, the material conditions exist where that knot can finally come undone.

  • Work for survival can be recognized as a solved, baseline logistical issue rather than a lifelong sentence.
  • Work for fulfillment—the human drive to learn, create, care, build, and solve meaningful problems—can finally exist for its own sake, rather than as a secondary byproduct of trying to stay alive.

This clarifies why the traditional label of “unemployment” creates such a massive blind spot. The current paradigm uses the word “work” as a bucket that dumps both categories together. It assumes that if you aren’t doing work for survival, you are doing nothing at all.

Saying “unemployment is good” cuts through that confusion. It points out that when survival labor is no longer required of you, human capacity isn’t extinguished—it is liberated. It is the space where genuine human flourishing and conscious development can finally begin on their own terms.

ME: Saying “unemployment is good” cuts through that confusion. It points out that when survival labor is no longer required of you, human capacity isn’t extinguished—it is liberated. It is the space where genuine human flourishing and conscious development can finally begin on their own terms.
This is true but it is a bit more nuanced – because work for survival is always part of being a human being living on planet earth. It is just there is a point where the survival aspect becomes easy enough to allow a flourishing of humanity’s creativity

AI: That is an essential correction, because treating survival work as something that can simply drop to zero drifts into techno-utopian fantasy.

We are biological organisms on a physical planet; staying alive will always require a baseline of real physical effort. Food must be grown, clothes washed, bodies cared for, and infrastructure maintained. Survival work is woven into the reality of being alive.

The historical shift isn’t the total disappearance of survival work—it is the collapse of its relative burden.

For almost all of human history, surviving took everything we had. From sunrise to sunset, nearly 100% of human energy, attention, and time was locked into keeping starvation, exposure, and disease at bay. Any art, philosophy, or deeper contemplation had to be snatched from the edges of absolute exhaustion or funded by the forced labor of an underclass.

What makes our current moment an evolutionary turning point is that the survival layer has finally become light enough to step out of the foreground:

  • From an all-consuming identity to background maintenance: Meeting the basic material requirements of life no longer needs to dictate the entire arc of an individual’s 40-year adulthood. It can function like breathing or brushing your teeth—a necessary, manageable baseline rather than the defining purpose of existence.
  • The creative threshold: Once the survival toll drops below that critical threshold, a massive surplus of human attention, stamina, and curiosity is left over.
  • The real meaning of “Unemployment”: In our current language, “unemployed” simply describes someone whose labor is no longer required by the survival machinery. If that machinery is already meeting the physical need with ease, that surplus time isn’t a vacuum or an error—it is the open territory where human creativity, relationships, and self-actualization can finally expand.

The tragedy of the current paradigm is that instead of letting survival remain that easy, manageable baseline, we keep inflating artificial tasks just to make survival feel hard again. We force people to spend 40 hours a week struggling just to earn the right to the baseline that should already be simple.

THE “MORE WORK” FALLACY

“…And there are those jobs that are not only boring and unpleasant, but would make little difference to our existence if they were not there, except that someone is earning a living from them…”

Again and again we read it in the papers and hear it on the news; politicians, economists and journalists telling us about the vital need for jobs. This preoccupation with the creation of jobs as a solution to the unemployment problem is at the top of the agenda for pretty much all sides of politics and economic thought. We by and large take the more jobs viewpoint as self-evident truth. Which is understandable – in our world you need a job to earn a living so as to survive. If there is not enough work available for everyone then people suffer.

On the other hand, when I see this world where overproduction seems to be one of our problems – where shops overflow with merchandise, where you can have every little want catered for, where resources are being rapidly depleted and where the environmental results of all this production press for urgent attention, then I can’t help but see an enormous contradiction in being told there is a need to create even more work for us to do.

So why do we need this “more work”?

As I see it there are three main reasons why we work.

The first and most basic of these reasons is to produce the things we need for living. We need food, houses, transport, energy, hospitals, plus a whole host of other things, and work is required to make them possible.

Another reason for working is for personal fulfilment. Whether it is simply to be an active member of the wider community or whether someone is drawn to a particular vocation, most people have a need for some form of activity to occupy their lives with.

The third reason for working is we work to earn a living. Working to earn a living is a crucial part of our economic system. It ensures we all do a fair share of the labour required to produce the stuff we need for living. We need money to gain access to the things necessary for survival and mostly we get that money from a paid job. This inturn ensures that everyone contributes to the general wealth – and it goes on. I know it seems like I am just stating the bleeding obvious here, but I’m attempting to point to something of great import that is usually overlooked in discussions about work and unemployment.

In our world it is essential to have a paid job. When economists and politicians talk about the need to create work it is primarily this third reason for working they are referring to.

In the complex world we live in these three types of work are present in countless variations and combinations. They rarely exist separately. Someone may have a job, a farmer for example; their work not only needs to be done, but also gives them fulfillment and earns them a living – thus combining all three types of work in the one job. As we unfortunately know, there are many jobs that people are only doing to earn a wage but get no satisfaction from and would much rather be somewhere else. And there are those jobs that are not only boring and unpleasant, but would make little difference to our existence if they were not there, except that someone is earning a living from them. More and more in our world the focus is on the third reason for working – working to earn a living.

When looking at these three reasons for working it is important to see that the first two are of a different kind than the third. Working to produce the things we need and working for fulfillment arise directly as a consequence of the physical and mental world we live in. Because we are physical beings we need food and shelter etc and must work to produce them. Because we are psychological/spiritual beings we have a need for a fulfilling life and a need to be part of a wider community.

Working to earn a living on the other hand, is of a different nature. It is a system we have developed to help make our lives more predictable, efficient and fair. Like the rules of the road it only exists because people developed it as a way to deal with a particular situation. Essentially it is a means of fairly distributing the fruits of our combined labour – I do some work, make my contribution to the economy, for which I am given a certain amount of rights, in the form of money, to take what I need from the system. This ensures that everyone does their fair share of the work and no-one abuses the system. Yes it is possible to manipulate things (legally and illegally) so more of the wealth comes my way, but by and large, with a lot of tweaking, the system has served us well. Until now that is.

Something in the working to earn a living system has changed to such an extent that no amount of tweaking is able to keep it operating effectively. In fact trying to keep the system operating as it always has, is resulting in many destructive side effects, such as; overproduction, the marginalised unemployed and soul destroying work lives of large sections of the workforce. It is also preventing a potential worldwide economic utopia from occurring in our lifetimes. No doubt there are many other things that prevent us from having a world where everyone has enough for a fulfilling life, but this is one of the least understood and acknowledged reasons.

What has changed and is causing the system to malfunction is our rising productivity.

Here are some productivity statistics from the OECD website. Based on GDP per hour worked, Australia’s productivity went from 56.1 in 1970 to 111.3 in 2013. That equates to a doubling of productivity per working person over a period of 43 years. Most industrialised western countries show similar figures to this. For the former eastern European communist countries the increase is even faster. Poland for example went from 55.5 in 1993 to 126.8 in 2013 – more than double the productivity in 20 years. For some of the industrialised Asian countries the figures are astounding. South Korea went from 13.7 in 1970 to 130.3 in 2013 – a tenfold rise in productivity.

productivity

While these sorts of figures are not perfect measurements, they do illustrate some significant trends. You could say that in Australia for example we are now able to produce what we did in 1970 with half the labour we needed then. More likely, as working hours have changed little in the last forty years, we are producing around twice as much as we did back then. No wonder it is so difficult to find more jobs for us to do – we are already so overloaded with stuff.

We have just had a guest staying for a few days who brought with her; the latest iphone, an ipod and a laptop – all loaded with 100’s of movies, games, videos and various ways of connecting to the internet. Add to that working, socialising and the practicalities of life, and there really isn’t room to fit in more things. If anything we need more space to properly enjoy the things we already have.

From this perspective, when we look at our economic system’s need for more jobs, it is clear we don’t want the more jobs because we need to produce more stuff. We rather need the jobs to give people access (through wages earned) to things that would have been produced whether they were working in their newly created jobs or not. And politicians and economists talk about even more productivity increases happening – so the problem can only get worse.

A possible solution to this problem can be seen if we look at this growth in productivity from a radically different perspective.

At the moment, each time there is growth in productivity we are left with two choices; there are less hours of work required for the same amount of production and so someone looses their job, or alternatively we produce even more things to give the newly sidelined workers a means to an income. What we rarely consider is; are there better ways to distribute the fruits of our production, to the displaced workers when improved technology or better organisation result in the need for less labour? In that way we would not be continually chasing more jobs – but could fully welcome all of the gifts that increased productivity gives us – then workers would not be seen to be loosing jobs but rather being freed from unnecessary work.

To go down this path of thought is to enter some very dangerous territory. It means a radical rethink of two of the central tenets of our economic system – work and money. As already shown, working to earn a living is a way we have developed to ensure everyone partakes in both the creation and the consumption of the fruits of our labour. It is not a direct outcome of our needs as the other two types of work are, but a system we have created in response to particular circumstances. So if the circumstances change – such as they have with our increased productivity – we are not compelled to continue with a system that can’t seem to deal with the change. We could if we wanted for example, have a 1970 lifestyle and only work 20 hours a week. Or say we still wanted half of the new inventions that have come post 1970, then the work week would be an average of 30 hours – or an extra 10 weeks off per year.

Some economists who argue against these sorts of ideas, put forward what they call “the lump of labour fallacy” or “the luddite fallacy”. They argue that while there may be short term job losses due to new technologies, in the longer term new jobs are always created to take the lost job’s place and so there is no great increase in unemployment. The mechanism whereby this happens is as follows. A new technology makes workers more productive – thus they earn higher wages. Those workers use their increased income to buy more things, thus creating work for the ones who were recently displaced by that new technology. The argument goes that you only have to look at employment levels since the beginning of the industrial revolution to see there has been no outbreak of mass unemployment due to new technology.

This lump of labour argument conveniently ignores one of the most astounding developments of the industrial revolution. Between 1870 and 1970 the average working week in industrialised countries reduced from around 65 hours to 39 hours (see graph) This is a reduction of 40% off the average working week.

work-hours-graphNow by far the majority of these reductions were made possible by labour saving machines. But say if instead of reducing working hours, we would have maintained a 65 hour work week, there would not be enough work for everyone and there would now be a technological unemployment rate of 40%. Technological unemployment and shorter working hours have a direct relationship – they are both outcomes of the same thing.

The mistake that those who espouse the lump of labour fallacy make is they see unemployment as something bad that needs to be avoided at all costs. Whereas the bulk of the workers who have an extra 25 hours a week to enjoy the fruits of the new technologies know it as a good thing.

Yet in spite of the evidence and commonsense logic, something compels us to persist with our working to earn a living system. – Money. – The general notion is that if someone loses their job because a machine has been invented that will do it faster and better – we have to ‘find the money’ somewhere for them to have a living – which usually means taking it from somewhere else. So often there ends up being less hospitals, or schools, or help for the needy, in order to pay for the results of our increased productivity. As productivity increases we seem to be running faster and faster just to stay in the same spot. I like the solution to this problem proposed by Alan Watts in his essay ‘Wealth Versus Money’. He says that the wealth generated by work done by machines should go to the general community to solve this problem. That something like this doesn’t happen may be one of the reasons why we see more and more of the wealth in our world being held by fewer and fewer people – usually the owners of the technology.

The majority of this essay has been about the ‘working’ part of working to earn a living. The ‘living’ part – usually meaning money – is of a similar nature. Money, like working to earn a living, is a system we have developed over many years to help us deal with the complexities of producing and distributing the fruits of our labour. It does not possess the degree of reality that the goods and services we produce have. In our world though, money has been given a place of equal if not greater importance than the goods and services it represents. For example, look at the global trade in money which largely has as its aim making profits from non-productive money transactions. The amount of money involved in these non-productive transactions is currently hundreds of times greater than the value of trade in real goods and services. So large are these financial markets that a collapse in any of them has the power to bring down the whole world economy (see the recent GFC). So we put enormous amounts of resources into making sure that a handful of investment banks don’t go bankrupt. The derivatives market has grown so large that there is just not enough money in existence to bail out banks if there was a major collapse.

Another example is world hunger. There is currently more than enough food being produced to feed everyone in the world, but because we put such a high priority on making more money, the priority of feeding the hungry is put in second place – or even further down the list.

There is a growing field called Modern Monetary Theory that points out  that governments can never be short of their own currency as they are the issuers of it. They have the power to issue themselves as much money as is needed to make use of the productive resources of the country. This could help in the transition to a higher productivity, lower working hour world.

To go into this in more detail is beyond the scope of this essay. Suffice it to say we have the materials and knowledge to produce enough for us all with far less worry and stress than we do at present and one of the reasons we are not doing this is our belief in the need for more work.

HAS THE ECONOMIC PROBLEM BECOME A PSYCHOLOGICAL PROBLEM?

…the economic problem is not-if we look into the future the permanent problem of the human race. Why, you may ask, is this so startling? It is startling because – if, instead of looking into the future, we look into the past – we find that the economic problem, the struggle for subsistence, always has been hitherto the primary, most pressing problem of the human race                                                                               John Maynard Keynes from Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren

Open any basic economic textbook and one of the first things you will see is a definition of the economic problem. It goes something like this; human needs and wants are always much greater than our ability to satisfy them. Put another way – resources are limited but human wants are never ending, therefore we have to make decisions about what is the most intelligent way to use our resources to create the greatest good for the greatest number of people. All economic systems and theories are born out of attempts to solve this problem.

An important question arises when looking at the problem of wants and needs – because obviously the needs of a poor African villager are very different to those of an affluent Westerner. As basic needs such as food and shelter are satisfied, needs and desires still arise, but they become less and less essential. This is the critical distinction between the concept of needs versus that of wants. Many economic theories try to deal with this difference. For example, we tax trivial wants such as luxury cars and then use those taxes to support more essential needs such as health care and education. But is it economically or psychologically wise to try to satisfy wants that are more and more trivial?

Most economists when they talk about the economic problem state that human wants are insatiable and then quickly pass on to the problem of how to satisfy these wants, rather than questioning the whole premise. Will satisfying insatiable desires really make us happy – is it even possible to satisfy them and what are the social and environmental consequences of trying to do so?

We have developed a technology that gives us the ability to provide for the comfortable living needs of everybody on the planet. We know how to do this with a minimum of drudgery. The prevailing idea that it is desirable to go on trying to satisfy trivial wants past this point only strengthens the bonds of our insecurities and feeds our addictions.

So is there a point where enough needs have been satisfied and we can say the economic problem has been solved – now we can really start living? I believe in most western countries we have gone well past that point. So much so that we now have an advertising industry whose job is to convince us we have needs that we otherwise would not have had. As well as this there is the sense of meaninglessness that many in the affluent west feel in spite of their material riches.

We are living at the remarkable time when, if we chose, we could declare the economic problem solved. One of the biggest impediments to being aware of this great possibility, let alone doing anything about it, is that we continue to look at the situation through outdated, psychologically simplistic economic theory.

– Unemployment is not a disease; so it has no cure

I love this extract from Robert Anton Wilson’s essay The Rich Economy

I don’t think there is, or ever again can be, a cure for unemployment. I propose that unemployment is not a disease, but the natural, healthy functioning of an advanced technological society.

The inevitable direction of any technology, and of any rational species such as Homo sap., is toward what Buckminster Fuller calls ephemeralization, or doing-more-with-less. For instance, a modern computer does more (handles more bits of information) with less hardware than the proto-computers of the late ’40’s and ’50’s. One worker with a modern teletype machine does more in an hour than a thousand medieval monks painstakingly copying scrolls for a century. …

Unemployment is not a disease; so it has no “cure.” …

Unemployment is directly caused by this technological capacity to do more-with-less. Thousands of monks were technologically unemployed by Gutenberg. Thousands of blacksmiths were technologically unemployed by Ford’s Model T. Each device that does-more-with-less makes human labor that much less necessary.

Aristotle said that slavery could only be abolished when machines were built that could operate themselves. Working for wages, the modern equivalent of slavery — very accurately called “wage slavery” by social critics — is in the process of being abolished by just such self-programming machines. In fact, Norbert Wiener, one of the creators of cybernetics, foresaw this as early as 1947 and warned that we would have massive unemployment once the computer revolution really got moving.

It is arguable, and I for one would argue, that the only reason Wiener’s prediction has not totally been realized yet — although we do have ever-increasing unemployment — is that big unions, the corporations, and government have all tacitly agreed to slow down the pace of cybernation, to drag their feet and run the economy with the brakes on. This is because they all, still, regard unemployment as a “disease” and cannot imagine a “cure” for the nearly total unemployment that full cybernation will create.

Suppose, for a moment, we challenge this Calvinistic mind-set. Let us regard wage-work — as most people do, in fact, regard it — as a curse, a drag, a nuisance, a barrier that stands between us and what we really want to do. In that case, your job is the disease, and unemployment is the cure.

“But without working for wages we’ll all starve to death!?! Won’t we?”

Not at all. Many farseeing social thinkers have suggested intelligent and plausible plans for adapting to a society of rising unemployment. Here are some examples.

1. The National Dividend. This was invented by engineer C. H. Douglas and has been revived with some modifications by poet Ezra Pound and designer Buckminster Fuller. The basic idea (although Douglas, Pound, and Fuller differ on the details) is that every citizen should be declared a shareholder in the nation, and should receive dividends on the Gross National Product for the year. …

2. The Guaranteed Annual Income. This has been urged by economist Robert Theobald and others. The government would simply establish an income level above the poverty line and guarantee that no citizen would receive less; if your wages fall below that level, or you have no wages, the government makes up the difference. …

3. The Negative Income Tax. This was first devised by Nobel economist Milton Friedman and is a less radical variation on the above ideas. The Negative Income Tax would establish a minimum income for every citizen; anyone whose income fell below that level would receive the amount necessary to bring them up to that standard. …

What I am proposing, in brief, is that the Work Ethic (find a Master to employ you for wages, or live in squalid poverty) is obsolete. Delivered from the role of things and robots, people will learn to become fully developed persons, in the sense of the Human Potential movement. They will not seek work out of economic necessity, but out of psychological necessity—as an outlet for their creative potential.

As Bucky Fuller says, the first thought of people, once they are delivered from wage slavery, will be, “What was it that I was so interested in as a youth, before I was told I had to earn a living?”

The answer to that question, coming from millions and then billions of persons liberated from mechanical toil, will make the Renaissance look like a high school science fair or a Greenwich Village art show.

–Unemployment Is A Distribution Problem Not A Production Problem

In current economic thinking unemployment is usually considered to be a production problem. That is when there is not enough production going on to make use of all the available labour you end up with some people left out of the whole economic cycle. The usual response to this is to try to create more work to absorb this excess labour. This is why we are compelled to continuously increase our production so as to keep ahead of the growing pool of unemployed.

But looked at from a broader perspective unemployment is not a problem of production but rather one of distribution.

Even if output goes down a little, as it has over the last year – putting more people out of work, our enormously productive technology still goes on churning out more than enough goods for us all. So we are not looking to find work for the unemployed because we need their labour to ensure we can produce enough. We are trying to find work for them so they can earn an income to gain access to the things that would be produced whether they were working or not. Wouldn’t it be simpler to just give it to them directly rather than go through this complicated process that results in so many negative side effects? (the marginalised unemployed, environmental problems of overproduction, the lack of fulfilment in trying to consume all this stuff, resources not being used where they are really needed – ie in ending hunger and poverty in the world for a start)

When I say – wouldn’t it be simpler to just give it to them directly – I’m not advocating having one section of the community sitting idly by while the rest of us work to support them. What I’m suggesting is that if we are already producing enough, we share the “less work” around equally and all work that much less while still having the same living standard as before. Paradoxically that would be an increase in living standard because the same living standard on less work is an increase in living standard.

-UNEMPLOYMENT IS GOOD #2

In the United States steel industry between 1982 and the year 2002 production rose from 77 million tons a year to 120 million tons. At the same time the number of workers employed in the industry went from 289,000 down to 74,000.

This is not an isolated occurrence. Similar statistics can be found in most industries in all industrialised countries. The reason is not complicated – better machines and greater efficiency means an increasing ability to produce more with less labour.

Surely this is a good thing. The only question is what do we do with it. How do we best realise the great gift our technology is offering us. For example, if the  statistics for steel were more or less representational of productivity increases in all industries, that would mean we could sustain 1982 living standards on a 10 hour work week. I know it’s not as simple as that: there are many post 1982 developments that we would not want to do without and some industries have not had the productivity increases that steel production has (though some have had more). I’m just using this example to indicate the scale of what is happening.

We are not even coming close to taking full advantage of the possibilities that technology opens up. While our great productivity has resulted in large increases in living standards, it has also helped to cause two of our biggest problems. On the one hand we generate unemployment, turning the machine freed workers into the out of work. On the other hand we desperately start producing more and more stuff to create work for the unemployed to do. We have created the twin problem of unemployment and a global and personal smothering in excess stuff, when we could just be having more and more free time.

And please, not free time to drink more beer and watch more television. But free time to give our lives more meaning and transform the world.

-UNEMPLOYMENT AS A POSITIVE ECONOMIC INDICATOR

Over the years whenever I’ve said “unemployment is good,” I’ve found I often need to qualify the statement. I don’t mean the suffering of those put out of work is good, or I don’t mean that lazing around doing nothing or living an unfulfilled life is good. I am talking about unemployment as an economic indicator. Usually unemployment is seen as a sign of something wrong with our economy. What I am saying is that it is a sign of a great opportunity that has the potential to transform our world for the better.

Most of the posts on this blog look at this issue from various perspectives. For me writing about it helps to develop my understanding of the question. I’m beginning to see that there is something here staring us in the face with it’s obviousness yet we remain oblivious. As the saying goes we have eyes but do not see.

-CHANGE OF HEART

I’m interested in paradigm shift. That is in seeing with new eyes, or simply being aware of how much our world is shaped by the cultural stories and beliefs we share. Often these world views are so ingrained we are unaware that we hold them. Some paradigms work well, others not so well. Some are just downright destructive.

Many of the paradigms that are contained in our world economic outlook are seriously questionable. Here are a few of them;

There is not enough to go around (scarcity) so we must compete for what there is. Most economic texbooks state this as the basic premise of economics. The industrial and technological revolutions have made this scarcity a thing of the past, yet we still persist in acting as if there is not enough.

Increasing production is good, decreasing production is bad. A corollary of this is that recession is bad. At the present time we constantly hear that world consumption and production have gone down, therefore we are in recession (which is bad) and we need to get out of it as fast as possible. Looking at this paradigm through new eyes, it is obvious that we are producing enough to satisfy our needs. If there is a possibility to cut  back on production and still meet our needs this is cause for celebration not hand wringing.

 The phrase ‘the bottom line’ is an accounting derived expression meaning the basic underlying truth or determining factor. In our world there is a paradigm that the bottom line (availability of money) is the bottom line, rather than being things like truth and goodness, or even from an economic perspective, that we have a technologically created abundance which enables everybody to be materially well looked after.

 There is the paradigm of consumerism that advertising so persavisely promotes. You won’t be happy unless you have more things. Brian Swimme goes into this in more detail in a very good essay titled ‘How do our kids get so caught up in consumerism’.

 One of the most powerful and least recognized economic paradigms is; money is a reality, rather than it is an abstract concept we have invented, as a tool to help us distribute the fruits of our labour. It is not a hard and fast reality, so if it has shortcomings it can be reinvented or even dispensed with to suit our needs. What often happens is that we have to detrimentally adjust our lives and the well-being of our world to fit in with the structure of money. I am reminded of the saying; ‘Only when the last tree has died and the last river been poisoned and the last fish been caught will we realise we cannot eat money’. Alan Watts’ essay Wealth Versus Money looks at this subject in a refreshing way.

 And of course what the title of this blog refers to. Unemployment is bad, versus unemployment is good. “Unemployment is good” does not mean that the suffering of individuals put out of work is good, but rather that if we can reduce the total amount of work needed to supply our living needs, then surely that is a good thing. This could release enormous amounts of time to do things that could contribute to a flowering of our civilisation – things such as the ending of poverty and hunger in the world.